Reading time: 12 minutes
With high impressions and low clicks, SEO changes on three fronts: queries, title and snippet, and citation in the summary. In short, fight for the click where it still exists. Elsewhere, fight for a citation in the AI Overview. Then CTR in Search Console shows, page by page, whether the change worked.
In short
- In the US, people who saw an AI summary clicked a traditional result in 8% of visits, against 15% without one, according to Pew Research Center.
- Searches for a site’s name, commercial searches and purchase searches rarely get an AI Overview. So they move up the priority list.
- Rewriting the title and snippet helps when the click went to another result. It does not help when a ready answer solved the search.
- Seer Interactive saw 120% more clicks per impression for a brand cited in the summary than for an uncited one.
Why does my site get high impressions and low clicks?
High impressions and low clicks mean your site shows up, but something else answers the search first. Google’s guide on traffic drops says the title and snippet may not convince, or another site has a more appealing rich result. The guide does not mention AI, but in our reading, the AI Overview at the top is the third suspect.
The passage is in Google’s guide to debugging traffic drops. Before you change any page, however, confirm the cause with a traffic drop diagnosis. Seasonality and tracking errors leave similar marks.
Likewise, how Search Console counts matters. A link cited in an AI Overview earns an impression even without a click. All links in the block get the same position. So an AI answer adds impressions while CTR in Search Console falls. The rules are in the guide to AI data in Search Console. AI Mode has its own Search Console guide.
What do the studies say about high impressions and low clicks?
All the studies below measure association, not cause. Pew Research Center tracked the browsing of 900 US adults in March 2025. People who saw an AI summary clicked a traditional result in 8% of visits, against 15% of those who did not. A click on a link inside the summary happened in just 1% of visits.
Ahrefs, which sells SEO tools, compared 300,000 keywords using aggregated Search Console data. In December 2025, an AI Overview was linked to a desktop CTR 58% lower for the first result and 50.8% lower for the second. However, Ahrefs does not say which country the sample comes from.
Seer Interactive, a search marketing agency, saw a partial recovery across 53 brands. With an AI Overview, organic CTR rose from 1.3% in December 2025 to 2.4% in February 2026. Google, by the way, disputes studies like these. On its AI features page, it says clicks from pages with an AI Overview are higher quality, and it publishes no numbers.

Which queries still get clicks when an AI Overview shows?
Queries where people want to act still get clicks: visiting a brand’s site, buying, hiring or finding a business nearby. The AI Overview rarely shows on these searches. Long questions, definitions and explanations, in contrast, often get a ready answer. As a result, they produce high impressions and low clicks.
Ahrefs analyzed 146 million desktop results pages from September 2025 and did not name the country. An AI Overview appeared in 21.4% of informational searches. It showed in only 4.3% of commercial searches and 2.1% of transactional ones. On navigational searches, those for a site’s name, the rate stayed below 1%.
Query length matters too, according to the Pew study. Only 8% of one- or two-word searches got an AI summary. For searches with 10 words or more, the share was 53%. Also, 60% of searches that began with “who,” “what,” “when” or “why” got a summary.
| Query type | What to expect | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| Site name | Almost no AI Overview | Keep title and landing page |
| Purchase and hiring | Little AI Overview | Prioritize product and service |
| Long question or definition | Frequent ready answer | Fight for the citation |
| Comparison and price | No clear rule | Test and measure case by case |
The table is ours and combines the two studies. So start with the queries that have high impressions and low clicks, and check whether the results page shows a summary. To do this at scale, see how to check whether a keyword has an AI Overview. For how to split the agenda between traffic, citation and conversion, see the guide to zero-click search.
Should you rewrite titles and descriptions to recover CTR?
Rewriting pays off when the result loses the click to another result, not to the ready answer. According to Google, the title link is often the main information people use to decide what to click. But Google builds the title and snippet from the page, so a rewrite only helps CTR in Search Console up to a point.
In its title link documentation, Google says title link generation is fully automated. It considers the title element, the main visible title, the H1, the og:title tag and even the links that point to the page. Also, a change shows up only after a recrawl, which may take a few days to a few weeks.
According to the snippet documentation, snippets come mainly from the page content and can change with each search. On the other hand, Google sometimes uses the meta description, when it describes the page more accurately than the content. So the first paragraph matters too.
When is the title behind high impressions and low clicks?
By our criterion, the title is the main suspect when the position is stable and no AI Overview shows on the queries that lost clicks. In that case, the page keeps high impressions and low clicks because the result next to it is more convincing. The routine we recommend has five steps:
- List the queries: in the Performance report, filter by page and sort by impressions.
- Search each one: note what appears above your site, such as a summary, a map or a rich result.
- Compare the titles: if there is no summary, see what competitors promise that your title does not.
- Rewrite title, H1 and opening: use the search term and say what the page offers that is different, such as price, data or a tool.
- Note the date: mark the change on the chart and wait for the recrawl before you measure CTR in Search Console.
To learn what rate to expect at each position, with and without a summary, see what a good organic CTR is in 2026.
Should you use nosnippet to force the click?
We do not recommend it. Google’s AI features and your website page sets a condition. A page can be a supporting link in AI Overviews and AI Mode only if it can show a snippet. The nosnippet, data-nosnippet and max-snippet controls limit what Search shows. In our reading, hiding the snippet also takes you out of the race for the citation. What changed in position zero is in the comparison of featured snippets and AI Overviews.
How do you get cited in the AI summary, not just listed below it?
To be cited, a page must be indexed, eligible to show with a snippet and included in the generative AI features in Search Console. After that, what matters is offering what AI cannot find anywhere else. According to Google, no special file, markup or schema is needed to appear in the answer.
A citation wins back part of the click. In Seer’s data, a brand cited in the AI Overview got 120% more clicks per impression than an uncited one. Even so, it stayed 38% below informational searches without a summary. Seer warns that this is correlation, since strong brands also get cited more. So on a query with high impressions and low clicks, being the summary’s source is the best outcome, but it does not bring back the old traffic.
Google’s guide to generative AI features in Search, updated in July 2026, asks for non-commodity content with a point of view and first-hand experience:
“Don’t just recycle what others on the internet have already said, or could easily be produced by a generative AI model.”
Google Search Central (2026)
In practice, we recommend four changes to pages that already rank:
- Answer first: each section opens with the direct answer, and the detail comes after.
- Subquestions on the same page: price, comparison, risks and alternatives become sections, not new pages.
- Something only the brand has: your own data, a test, a client case or a price table.
- A checked control: in Search Console settings, the generative AI in Search option must be set to include.
How AI Overviews and AI Mode choose their sources is in the guide to Google AI Mode and AI Overviews. The technical side, from crawling to indexing, is in the guide to SEO and AI.
Which content do AI summaries skip, so it still earns visits?
AI summarizes less of what calls for an action or for data only your site has. That includes tools, calculators, downloadable templates, price comparisons, product pages and local pages. On these pages, the summary points to the site instead of replacing it.
In Ahrefs’ data, an AI Overview showed on 47.3% of definition searches and 59.8% of those asking for a reason, against 20.5% on average. In other words, the more a search looks like an encyclopedia question, the likelier it is to get a ready answer.
Which pages should you keep with high impressions and low clicks?
Keep the page that works through a path other than the click. In our reading, a page with high impressions and low clicks still pays off in three cases:
- It is cited: it has impressions in the generative AI report and appears in answers on the topic.
- It converts: it brings few visitors, but they become leads or sales.
- It teaches AI about the brand: price, policy, deadlines and support, which the answer needs to get right.
Rand Fishkin of SparkToro points to the third case: the support article must exist for the AI Overview to get the answer right. So cut or merge only generic text that has no AI impressions, does not convert and says nothing about the brand.
How do you track in Search Console whether the change worked?
Compare the same page before and after the change, with the same country, device and period length. In the Performance report, look at CTR in Search Console and at the clicks on the queries you targeted. In the generative AI report, check whether AI impressions went up. Finally, GA4 shows whether visitors engaged and converted.
The generative AI performance report reached all sites on August 31, 2026. It shows only impressions by page, with no clicks or queries. Clicks from these answers are added to regular search, under the Web type. So CTR in Search Console mixes the two worlds, and you must read it page by page. If a page keeps high impressions and low clicks but gained AI impressions, in our reading it may have gained ground as a source for the summary.
Which metrics matter beyond impressions and clicks?
CTR in Search Console tells you whether the title worked. It does not tell you whether the brand entered the answer. So we recommend a dashboard with five metrics per page, always cut the same way:
| Metric | Where to see it | What it shows |
|---|---|---|
| CTR and clicks by query | Performance report | Whether title and snippet worked |
| AI impressions | Generative AI report | Exposure in AI Overviews and AI Mode |
| Branded search clicks | Branded filter | Who searched for the brand by name |
| Engagement and conversions | GA4, Organic Search | Whether the visit paid off |
| Brand presence | Fixed prompts | Mention and citation in answers |
Three precautions prevent wrong readings. First, note each change on the chart, because Search Console annotations accept notes of up to 120 characters. Second, the branded and non-branded filter does not appear for sites with few impressions. Finally, a logging error affected impressions from May 2025 to April 2026, but not clicks. So in a year-over-year comparison, use clicks.
Brand presence in answers does not show up in Search Console CTR. So measure it with fixed prompts, repeated every month, as in the protocol to measure brand mentions and citations in AI.
What do you say when asked if SEO still works?
Answer with what the site delivers, not just traffic. Show clicks and conversions from the queries that still call for a visit, impressions and citations in AI answers, and brand searches. In our reading, SEO remains the foundation, because Google says AI features use the same search practices.
So a site with high impressions and low clicks shifts the focus of the work, not the foundation.
For the client or the board, we suggest three blocks: what dropped and why, what held and what changed on the pages. In each block, show CTR in Search Console before and after. The numbers for 2025 and 2026 are in the analysis of whether SEO is still worth it. For the return math, when part of the value comes before the click, see the guide to SEO and GEO ROI.
Main sources
- Google Search Central, debugging drops in Google Search traffic (2025).
- Google Search Central, influencing title links in search results (2025).
- Google Search Central, controlling your snippets in search results (2026).
- Google Search Central, AI features and your website (2025).
- Pew Research Center, clicks on searches with an AI summary (2025).
- Ahrefs, update to the study on how AI Overviews affect CTR (2026).
- Ahrefs, which kinds of searches get an AI Overview, across 146 million results pages (2025).
- Seer Interactive, impact of AI Overviews on CTR, April update (2026).



