Is GEO worth it for my client? Six objections and how to answer

A meeting cheat sheet for agencies: six GEO objections from clients (“it’s a fad”, “we already do SEO”, “AI doesn’t drive clicks”, “what if AI gets it wrong”, “you can’t measure it” and “my competitor already shows up”), a short answer for each, the open source and what not to promise.
Written with AI, reviewed by humans

In this article

See how your brand shows up in AI answers

Book a demo and find out what to fix first, with a GEO specialist.

Book a demo

Reading time: 11 minutes

GEO is worth it when the client depends on being remembered in AI answers and the agency can measure it, but no one should promise the result in the meeting. This guide covers six GEO objections from clients. Each one comes with a short answer, the open source behind it and what the agency should not promise.

In short

  • GEO objections from clients are often fair doubts. So the best answer starts by agreeing with the true part.
  • Google says that, for Search, optimizing for AI is still SEO. So “GEO is a fad” and “we already do SEO” call for the same move: show what changes in practice.
  • AI drives fewer clicks and gets brands wrong. So instead of denying it, measure presence, fix the source and do not promise volume or position.
  • To say whether GEO is worth it, the agency uses the client’s own data and ends every answer with what it does not promise.

What are the six GEO objections from clients, and the short answer to each?

The table below sums up the GEO objections from clients. Each row shows the doubt, a one-sentence answer and what the agency should not promise. So read the table before the meeting and go back to the source section when the doubt comes up.

ObjectionShort answerDo not promise
“GEO is a fad”The name is new, but for Google the work is still SEO.That AI will overtake Google
“We already do SEO”SEO is the base, but it does not show whether AI names the brand.That today’s ranking guarantees a mention
“AI doesn’t drive clicks”It drives fewer, so the proof includes presence and leads.Visit volume
“What if AI gets my brand wrong?”It does, so the agency checks the answers and fixes the source.That AI never errs, or a fix date
“You can’t measure it”You can, because the report uses many repeated prompts and a margin of error.Exact position in the answer
“My competitor already shows up”They do, and the gap may sit in third-party sources you can map.Passing the competitor by a date

First, agree with the true part of the doubt. Then show the source and say what the agency does not promise. The full sales script, with pitch, first meeting and pilot, is in the guide on how to sell GEO services. Here, the focus is only the GEO objections from clients.

GEO objections and whether GEO is worth it: agency meeting with a laptop and notes on the table

GEO objection: how to answer “GEO is a fad”?

Answer that the name is new, but the buyer behavior it describes has already changed, and that the work is still SEO. Google itself writes that optimizing for generative AI search is optimizing for the search experience, and thus “still SEO.”

The buyer has changed too. G2 surveyed 1,076 B2B decision-makers in March 2026, in a global sample (North America, EMEA and Asia-Pacific). It reports that 51% of B2B software buyers start research with an AI chatbot more often than with Google, but the page does not state the base of that figure. The result covers software buyers only, not consumers or other categories, and it is self-reported. G2 also sells software review products. Among the GEO objections from clients, this is the one with an official source from Google itself.

  • Agree with: the term is new, so there is hype around it.
  • Answer: the agency does not sell an acronym. It sells care for what AI says about the client’s category. When the client asks if GEO is worth it, start with this buyer behavior.
  • Do not promise: that AI search will overtake Google.

GEO objection: how to answer “we already do SEO”?

Answer that SEO is the base of GEO, but an SEO report does not show whether AI names the brand. According to Google, a page only appears as a supporting link in AI Overviews and AI Mode if it is indexed and eligible to be shown with a snippet. There are no additional technical requirements. In other words, a page that is already indexed and snippet-eligible meets the technical entry bar.

So when the client asks if GEO is worth it, the SEO they already pay for is the starting point. Entering, however, is not appearing. Google warns that meeting the requirements does not mean it will show the page. Also, there is one technical point worth checking: AI crawlers. According to OpenAI, sites that block OAI-SearchBot do not show up in ChatGPT search answers, although they can appear as navigational links.

In our view, with no outside source, there is also a second difference. The rankings report shows where the page sits in Google’s list, but not in how many AI answers the brand is named. Among the GEO objections from clients, this one comes from people who already hire the agency.

  • Agree with: the client already pays for part of the work, and that part counts.
  • Answer: GEO adds a check of the AI crawlers and a measurement of the answers.
  • Do not promise: that a good ranking guarantees a mention. The way to propose GEO to a client who already pays for SEO is in the guide on a GEO upsell for the SEO client base.

GEO objection: how to answer “AI doesn’t drive clicks”?

Answer that the objection is true and that, for this reason, the proof of GEO cannot be visits alone. The Pew Research Center tracked 900 U.S. adults in March 2025. Those who saw an AI summary clicked a traditional result in 8% of visits, against 15% for those who did not.

Clicking a link inside the summary itself happened in 1% of visits to pages with that summary. But this is a comparison, not proof of cause.

The shift is bigger than AI. In the U.S., 68.01% of Google searches ended without a click from January to April 2026, according to SparkToro, using a Similarweb panel that does not include the Google app. SparkToro sells audience research software. So the underlying doubt is whether GEO is worth it without the click. The agency answers with other signals: presence in answers, AI sessions, impressions and leads, each with its own limit. The guide on how to prove GEO results details these proofs.

  • Agree with: fewer clicks is what the data shows.
  • Answer: the goal is for the brand to be remembered where the decision happens, and that is measured with other signals.
  • Do not promise: visit volume from the AI channel, or higher sales.

GEO objection: how to answer “what if AI gets my brand wrong”?

Answer that AI does get things wrong, so someone needs to check what it says and fix the source. In Searchable‘s study, with 1,704 brands from several countries, brands flagged 9.2% of 32,556 facts as incorrect. Among brands that reviewed 20 facts or more, 3 in 4 found at least one false fact.

AI erred most on pricing (13.5%), funding and financials (10.9%) and integrations and tech stack (10.6%). However, Searchable sells AI monitoring, and employees of the brands themselves graded the facts. So the number gives an order of magnitude, not a market error rate.

Likewise, Google admits the problem. According to the Search Help page, AI Overviews can and will make mistakes. The page tells users to use the thumbs-down icon and Report a problem, but it gives no deadline. So the first step is to note the error and find the page that caused it.

  • Agree with: the risk is real, especially on pricing.
  • Answer: GEO includes checking the answers about the brand, noting the error and then fixing the source.
  • Do not promise: that AI will never err again, or a date for the fix.

GEO objection: how to answer “you can’t measure it”?

Answer that you can, but not by position: you measure the brand’s presence rate across many repeated prompts, with a margin of error. After all, a single check misleads. For example, in a SparkToro study, 600 volunteers ran 12 prompts 2,961 times.

The chance that ChatGPT or Google’s AI gives the same list of brands in any two responses was below 1 in 100. Although the research had help from Gumshoe.ai, a startup in AI tracking, SparkToro declares this possible conflict of interest.

The margin of error, in turn, comes from the sample size. The math is ours, at 95% confidence, and comes from the guide on how to measure brand visibility:

  • 250 answers per month: ± 6 to ± 14 points.
  • 1,000 answers per month: ± 3 to ± 7 points.
  • Real change: only a swing above 4 to 10 points, confirmed the next month.

So the “you can’t measure it” objection gets an honest answer:

  • Agree with: the position in an AI answer changes on every run, so anyone who sells that position as certain misleads the client.
  • Answer: the report shows presence with the margin of error and, for this reason, says “no proven change” when the swing fits inside it. Without this measurement, no one knows if GEO is worth it for that brand.
  • Do not promise: an exact position in the answer, or a tool score without the formula next to it.

GEO objection: how to answer “my competitor already shows up”?

Answer that the competitor does show up, but that you can measure in how many answers, and that the gap may sit in third-party sources. BuzzStream, which sells public relations software, analyzed 12,000 answers from Google’s AI Overviews, AI Mode and Gemini and from an OpenAI model.

For example, on category questions, such as “Best project management tools,” only 7.2% of the mentions of a brand came with the brand’s domain cited in the same answer. The study does not state the country. In other words, on these questions the brand is often named without its own site being cited. An earlier BuzzStream study, summarized on the same page, found that most citations come from third-party sources.

So the first step is to run the category questions, note who appears and open the cited sources. The map of these sources is in the guide on why ChatGPT recommends your competitor. Among the GEO objections from clients, this is the one that most needs a diagnosis before the answer.

  • Agree with: seeing the rival in the answer is annoying, so the complaint is fair.
  • Answer: the diagnosis shows in how many answers each brand appears and which pages support the competitor.
  • Do not promise: passing the competitor by a date, or that the list of brands will repeat.

What should the agency not promise when answering GEO objections?

In all six answers, the limit is the same: the agency controls deliverables, method and report, but not the AI’s answer. Google writes, “Indexing and serving isn’t guaranteed.” So the contract and the meeting describe what the agency does, not what ChatGPT or Google answers.

If the client insists on a guarantee, use the lines and the sample clause from the guide on the client who wants a guarantee to appear in ChatGPT. That way, the GEO objections from clients end in a commitment the client can check. Finally, whether GEO is worth it is the client’s decision, and the agency helps with data, not with promises.

Frequently asked questions

Is GEO worth it for every client?

It depends on the client, since no source in this guide answers that for them. There are signs that buyers use AI, such as the 51% of software buyers in the G2 survey, and Google treats the work as SEO. So the prudent path is to measure the client’s brand before proposing a scope.

Do the numbers cited apply to my client’s market?

Not directly. Pew and SparkToro’s no-click figure measure the U.S., and G2 surveyed B2B software buyers in three regions. Searchable gathers brands from several countries, and BuzzStream does not state the country. So use these numbers as context in the GEO objections from clients and bring the client’s own brand data to the meeting.

Can I tell the client that GEO brings more sales?

No, because no source in this guide shows that GEO generates sales, and Google says serving is not guaranteed. Promise deliverables, a fixed method and a report with a margin of error.

Want to know how your brand shows up in AI answers today?

Book a demo and see how your brand shows up in AI answers, with support from a GEO specialist.

Main sources

  • Google Search Central, guide to optimizing for generative AI features (2026).
  • Google Search Central, AI features and your website (2026).
  • G2, research on AI search and software buying (2026).
  • Pew Research Center, clicks on results with an AI summary (2025).
  • SparkToro, Google searches that still send a click (2026).
  • Searchable, report on misinformation about brands in AI (2026).
  • SparkToro, study on the inconsistency of AI brand recommendations (2026).
  • BuzzStream, study on brand mentions and citations in AI answers (2026).
About this articleWritten with AI and reviewed by humans, with verified sources. Found something out of date? Write to the NotHuman team.

Get new NotHuman articles by email

By subscribing, you agree to receive blog articles by email and to the Privacy Policy. Unsubscribe any time.

Keep reading

Demo

Want to know how your brand shows up in AI answers today?

Book a demo and see how your brand shows up in AI answers, with support from a GEO specialist.

Book a demo

Your privacy

We use necessary cookies to make the site work and Google Analytics and Microsoft Clarity statistics cookies to improve our content. You can decline the statistics ones; in the EU, UK and Switzerland they are only turned on after you accept. Cookie Policy.

Cookie preferences

Cookie Policy