Reading time: 11 minutes
No one can give a guarantee to appear in ChatGPT, not even OpenAI. So the agency should say that to the client and promise what it controls: deliverables, method and measurement. This guide covers what the platforms say, ready-made lines for the meeting and an example no guarantee clause to review with a lawyer.
In short
- OpenAI says placement in ChatGPT search results is not guaranteed. Google says the same about indexing and serving in its AI features.
- AI answers change with every run. In a SparkToro study, for example, the chance of repeating the same list of brands was below 1 in 100.
- Instead of guaranteeing a citation, the agency commits to deliverables, a fixed method and a report with a margin of error.
- The no guarantee clause in this guide is an example, not legal advice.
Is there a ChatGPT guarantee?
No. No agency or tool can give a ChatGPT guarantee, because the engine decides which sites to show. According to OpenAI, as we read its Help Center on October 27, 2026, ChatGPT ranks results using multiple factors, and “Placement is not guaranteed.”
The agency, however, controls eligibility. To let a site in, the same page says to allow the OAI-SearchBot crawler and confirm that the host or CDN accepts its IP addresses. Also, on the crawlers page, OpenAI says sites that block the bot will not appear in ChatGPT search answers. They can still show up as navigational links.
In other words, allowing the bot is a condition to get in, but it is not a guarantee to stay. The steps an agency can take are in the guide on how to show up in ChatGPT.

What do OpenAI and Google say about guarantees?
Both say they do not guarantee it. Neither offers a guarantee to appear in ChatGPT or in Google’s AI features. OpenAI says ChatGPT placement is not guaranteed. Google, for its part, says indexing and serving in AI features are not guaranteed. Also, no one can guarantee first place in search. So the client can check each line at the source.
| Company | What it says | Where |
|---|---|---|
| OpenAI | Placement is not guaranteed | ChatGPT help |
| Indexing and serving in AI are not guaranteed | AI features | |
| No one guarantees first place | Do you need an SEO? | |
| A service or tool does not guarantee ranking | Third-party SEO |
Google, by the way, goes further. On the AI features page, the company says there are no additional requirements to appear in AI Overviews and AI Mode. There is no special optimization either. Also, meeting every best practice does not mean Google will show the page.
On the page about hiring an SEO, Google writes: “No one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google.” On the same page, Google calls an SEO who promises to guarantee rankings a red flag. So an informed client may read a promise of a guarantee with suspicion.
Why does the ChatGPT answer change from one run to the next?
Because the same question gets different answers on each run. In a SparkToro study of ChatGPT, Claude and Google’s AI, the chance that ChatGPT or Google’s AI repeats the same list of brands in two answers was below 1 in 100. So the list of brands can change from one answer to another with no mistake by the agency, and a ChatGPT guarantee makes no sense.
The study gathered 600 volunteers, who ran 12 prompts 2,961 times in what SparkToro calls the three most popular AI tools in the US. A professional from Gumshoe.ai, a startup in the AI tracking sector, helped with the research. SparkToro declares this possible conflict of interest. The factors that change the answer are in the guide on why ChatGPT gives different answers to the same question.
Because the answer varies, the measurement varies too. According to the table in the guide on how to measure brand visibility, 30 answers per month give a margin of error of ± 18 to ± 31 points. Imagine, for example, that the brand shows up in 12 of those 30 answers, or 40%. In this hypothetical case, the real rate could be between 22% and 58% with the smaller margin, and between 9% and 71% with the larger one.
On the other hand, with 1,000 answers per month, the margin falls to ± 3 to ± 7 points. Even so, only a change above 4 to 10 points, confirmed the next month, counts as a real change. So a ChatGPT guarantee would need a stable number, and that number does not exist.
What should you tell a client who asks for a ChatGPT guarantee?
Answer in three steps: say that no one guarantees it, show the source and offer what the agency does guarantee. First of all, ask what “appear” means to the client. It can be the brand name in the answer, a citation with a link or a recommendation, and each one is measured in a different way.
The table gives short answers to the most common questions. It is an editorial suggestion from NotHuman, so the agency can adapt the tone.
| The client asks | You answer |
|---|---|
| “Do you guarantee we will appear?” | “No one guarantees it, not even OpenAI. We guarantee the work and the measurement.” |
| “So what do you guarantee?” | “The contract deliverables, a fixed method and a monthly report with a margin of error.” |
| “Another agency guarantees it.” | “OpenAI says placement is not guaranteed. It is worth asking how they deliver on that.” |
| “What if we don’t appear?” | “The report shows what changed and what is missing, and we adjust the plan.” |
| “How long until we appear?” | “The deadline for deliverables is ours, but the timing of a citation depends on the engine.” |
| “Can we pay to appear?” | “Ads are another channel, with their own budget and rules. I can show you.” |
On the last row, the guide on how to advertise on ChatGPT explains the paid channel. As for timing, OpenAI says a robots.txt change takes about 24 hours to take effect in search. That, however, does not say when the page will be cited.
The core answer is always the same: the agency does not sell a ChatGPT guarantee, but measured work. Finally, use a 30-second answer to close the meeting. Replace the fields in brackets:
No one can guarantee that an AI will cite a
brand, not even OpenAI itself. What
[AGENCY] guarantees is what depends on it:
[DELIVERABLES] on the agreed dates. Every
month you see what changed, with the margin
of error, and we decide the next step
together.
Is promising a ChatGPT guarantee a legal risk?
Yes, it can be. In the US, the FTC’s advertising guide for small businesses says “Advertisers must have evidence to back up their claims.” It adds that an implied claim is one “made indirectly or by inference.” A promise of a ChatGPT guarantee is a claim about a result the agency does not control, so it would be hard to back with evidence.
In a 2024 announcement on deceptive AI claims, the FTC said there is “no AI exemption from the laws on the books.” These rules cover advertising claims. Whether a sales promise to one client falls under them, and how the EU or UK rules apply, are questions for a lawyer. This is general information, not legal advice.
What should you promise instead of a guarantee?
Instead of a ChatGPT guarantee, promise what the agency controls: deliverables with deadlines, a fixed measurement method and accountability. These are three commitments the client can check, even when the AI answer moves. So the table swaps each guarantee for a commitment that the agency can meet and the client can verify.
| Instead of guaranteeing | Commit to | The client checks in |
|---|---|---|
| Citation in ChatGPT | Diagnosis and technical fixes | Finished checklist |
| Position in the list | [N] pages reviewed per month | List of URLs |
| Deadline to appear | Deadline of each deliverable | Schedule |
| More sales from the channel | Monthly report, same method | Spreadsheet and margin |
Also, Google itself suggests that the client ask the SEO what results to expect, in what timeframe and how success is measured. On the page about hiring an SEO, the company also says an audit should give realistic estimates. So have these answers ready before the meeting.
Presence goals can go in, but as a tracked target. For example, the proposal says “track the presence rate, with a goal of [X]%”, and the report says whether the change went beyond the margin of error. This way, the contract does not turn into a ChatGPT guarantee. These lines become contract text in the no guarantee clause in the next section. The full scope is in the proposal template mentioned in the next section.
How do you write a no guarantee clause?
A no guarantee clause says, in plain language, that the agency does not guarantee a citation, mention or position in an AI engine, and it lists what the agency does guarantee. This way, it aligns expectations when the client demands a ChatGPT guarantee. The text below is an example to adapt. It is not legal advice, so ask a lawyer to review the final contract.
CLAUSE [X]. NO GUARANTEE OF RESULTS
[X].1 AI engine answers vary with each run
and depend on factors that [AGENCY] does
not control. For this reason, [AGENCY] does
not guarantee a citation, mention, position
or recommendation of the brand in an AI
engine, or a deadline for that to happen.
[X].2 [AGENCY] commits to:
a) the deliverables in Annex [N], on the
dates in the schedule;
b) the measurement method in Annex [N],
with defined prompts, engines and period;
c) a monthly report with a margin of error.
[X].3 [CLIENT] commits to release access
and approve materials within [N] days.
Delays move the delivery dates.
[X].4 Changes within the margin of error
do not indicate improvement or decline in
the work.
Each item of the no guarantee clause has a job. First, item 1 says what the agency does not guarantee and why. Second, item 2 lists what it does guarantee, so the clause does not look like an escape from responsibility. Item 3 reminds the client that it also provides access and approvals. Finally, item 4 avoids a dispute over normal swings.
But payment terms, penalties, termination and validity are for the lawyer, because contract rules vary by country and by US state. The GEO proposal template has a similar block inside a full proposal, with scope, deliverables and a schedule.
What if the client insists on a ChatGPT guarantee?
If the client insists, explain the risk and offer a pilot with an exit criterion. After all, accepting a ChatGPT guarantee means taking on a result that the agency does not control. Declining politely and showing the source is also a professional answer.
- Show the sources: the OpenAI page and the Google page weigh more than the agency’s opinion, and the no guarantee clause records the deal.
- Offer a pilot: a closed scope, with repeated measurement and an agreed exit, as the guide on how to sell GEO services describes.
- Avoid an improvised refund: a penalty or refund for no citation is a business and legal decision. If the agency offers one, it defines the criterion, the period and the margin of error in writing.
After signing, the client needs to see the work. So take the numbers that the contract sets and the deliverables already made to the report.
Frequently asked questions
Yes. Google says indexing and serving in AI features are not guaranteed. Also, there are no additional requirements or special optimization to appear in AI Overviews and AI Mode. So the no guarantee clause should cover every engine, as the guide on Google AI Mode explains.
Yes, as a tracked goal. With 1,000 answers per month, the margin of error is ± 3 to ± 7 points. Only a change above 4 to 10 points, confirmed the next month, counts as a real change. So write the goal as a tracked target, not as an obligation.
It does not solve the root problem, because the result stays outside the agency’s control. Offering a refund is a business and legal decision for each agency. If the agency offers one, it should define the criterion, the period and the margin of error in writing, and ask a lawyer to review it.
Main sources
- OpenAI, searching the web with ChatGPT (2026).
- OpenAI, overview of the crawlers (2026).
- Google Search Central, AI features and your website (2025).
- Google Search Central, do you need an SEO? (2026).
- Google Search Central, third-party SEO tools and advice (2026).
- FTC, advertising FAQ’s: a guide for small business (2001, edited 2025).
- FTC, FTC announces crackdown on deceptive AI claims and schemes (2024).
- SparkToro, study on how inconsistent AI brand recommendations are (2026).



